Panthers 20, Saints 17: Fitzgerald's 54-yard field goal wins it with two seconds left
By Jordan Vance
Updated Monday, Nov. 16.
Two kickers decided this one. Charlie Smyth tied it for New Orleans with a 55-yard field goal with 45 seconds left. Ryan Fitzgerald won it for Carolina from 54 yards with two seconds on the clock. Final: 20-17.
Carolina led 7-0 at halftime and 10-7 after three quarters. The lead changed hands twice in the last four minutes before the final kick.
New Orleans: Kamara scored everything, and nothing else worked
Alvin Kamara scored both Saints touchdowns, a 3-yard run in the third quarter and a 4-yard catch from Tyler Shough with 3:53 left. Both scores came inside five yards, which is where this offense finished drives when it could not gain much between the 20s.
It rarely could. New Orleans ran 23 times for 49 yards. Shough, in his second season, completed 25 of 35 passes but gained only 187 yards, about five yards a throw. He threw one interception, and the Saints lost a fumble. Carolina did not turn the ball over once.
Carolina: a goal-line back and a long-range kicker
Chuba Hubbard scored both Carolina touchdowns, from 2 yards and 1 yard. The Panthers' passing game produced 200 yards and no touchdowns, and the team ran 32 times for 97 yards.
Carolina also committed 17 penalties for 152 yards, a franchise record, and still won. Fitzgerald made kicks of 55 and 54 yards and missed one from the 40s.
Injuries and key news
No skill-position injuries were reported. Saints linebacker Pete Werner (hamstring) was ruled out. The result hurts New Orleans' playoff hopes.
How it unfolded
Neither team scored in the first quarter. Carolina broke through in the second when Chuba Hubbard ran in from two yards, and the Panthers held a 7-0 lead at halftime.
New Orleans tied it on a 3-yard run by Kamara early in the second half. Fitzgerald's 55-yard field goal put Carolina back in front 10-7 late in the third quarter, and neither team scored again for more than 13 minutes.
The fourth quarter held all the movement. Shough hit Kamara for a 4-yard touchdown with 3:53 left to make it 14-10. Carolina took the lead back 2:02 later when Hubbard ran in from the 1. Then Smyth's 55-yarder tied it with 45 seconds left, and Fitzgerald's 54-yarder won it 43 seconds later.
What it means for dynasty rosters
Kamara. Two touchdowns from inside five yards show he still gets the Saints' scoring touches. He is 31, and running backs usually peak between 24 and 27, so his value is a short-window one. A contender can lean on the touchdowns. A rebuilding roster should not pay a price built on next year.
Shough. Twenty-five completions that bought 187 yards is a short-passing line, and the interception cost New Orleans a drive. One game does not settle a second-year quarterback, but it does not move him up either.
Hubbard. Carolina gave him the ball at the 2 and the 1. That is the best role a back can have for scoring, and it is why his weekly floor holds even when the passing game gives him nothing.
FAQ
Is Alvin Kamara still worth holding in dynasty? For a contender, yes. Both Saints touchdowns went through him. For a long rebuild, no. At 31 his value is near-term, so hold only if you are competing this season.
Does Chuba Hubbard's two-touchdown game make him a dynasty starter? It shows the goal-line role is his. Both Carolina touchdowns came from inside the 3-yard line. The ground game as a whole averaged three yards a carry, so the role is secure but the production around it is thin.
Did Tyler Shough help or hurt his dynasty value in Week 10? Neither much. He moved the offense on short throws and threw for one touchdown, but he also threw an interception and averaged about five yards per attempt. It is a neutral game for a second-year quarterback.