Steelers-Colts Week 5 Recap: Warren's 188 Yards Win It 34–22
By Jordan Vance
Jaylen Warren made the Colts' defense look slow all afternoon. He scored on an 80-yard catch and a 50-yard run, finished with 188 yards from scrimmage, and Pittsburgh beat Indianapolis 34–22 at Acrisure Stadium. The Steelers are 3–2 and unbeaten at home, and they bounced back from a loss at Cleveland. Three times Indianapolis pulled within a point, and each time Pittsburgh answered behind Warren.
Steelers coach Mike McCarthy called Warren "the man," and the numbers explain why. Jaylen Warren ran 15 times for 101 yards and a touchdown, caught all six of his targets for 87 yards and another, and finished as the top fantasy scorer in the game by a wide margin. He came into the league as an undrafted rookie free agent, and AP's game story described the day as a showcase for that journey. The two long scores accounted for most of his yards. His 80-yarder came on a short pass from Aaron Rodgers, and his 50-yard run gave Pittsburgh a 24–16 lead in the third quarter.
Rodgers and Pittsburgh
Rodgers had another clean game. He completed 22 of 31 passes for 235 yards and three touchdowns, the third straight week he has thrown for at least three, which ties a Steelers record. Only Terry Bradshaw had done it for the franchise before. Rodgers hit Warren for the 80-yarder and Pat Freiermuth for two touchdowns. The second Freiermuth touchdown came with 6:40 left and gave Pittsburgh a nine-point lead. Chris Boswell added a long field goal to make it 34–22 with 3:43 to play. Germie Bernard caught six of nine targets for 80 yards, and DK Metcalf caught three of four for 12.
Indianapolis
Indianapolis moved the ball and could not finish. Daniel Jones threw for 267 yards on 24 of 44 passing without a touchdown pass or an interception, and the Colts went 1 for 3 in the red zone, 4 of 15 on third down and 3 of 5 on fourth. Spencer Shrader kicked five field goals, two of them from beyond 55 yards early and three short ones after drives stalled from the 4, 10 and 22. Early in the fourth quarter, a 20-yard run by Jonathan Taylor put the Colts at the Pittsburgh 10, and Jones then threw three straight incompletions before a 28-yard field goal. Colts coach Shane Steichen said his team settled for too many field goals.
The Colts moved the ball between the 20s all day, and that made the red zone failures more costly. The Steelers' defense bent and did not break, which has been the pattern in their home wins. Tyler Warren caught seven of nine targets for 83 yards and scored on a 1-yard run. Josh Downs and Keenan Allen combined for eight catches, and Jones attempted 44 passes in a game he was never able to take control of. Taylor was held in check, and the Pittsburgh defense gave the Colts little on the ground. Laquon Treadwell caught two of eight targets, which is a poor return on that volume. The Steelers have now beaten Indianapolis 10 times in 12 meetings.
The Colts are 2–3 after beating Washington in London the week before.
Lineup calls
Warren is a strong start, though two long touchdowns will not repeat every week. His 15 carries and six catches show a steady role. Rodgers is on a hot streak, and Freiermuth's two touchdowns make him a start in the short term. Bernard's nine targets matter more than Metcalf's four, and Metcalf's quiet day is the number to follow. For Indianapolis, Shrader's five field goals made him the third-best fantasy scorer in the game, and Tyler Warren keeps his role as the top target. Taylor's 45 yards on 15 carries are a warning sign.